Straight Dallas overtime eliminations, because one ending wasn't humiliating enough
The refs erased Dallas's first overtime winner, and Colorado treated it like a divine intervention. Matt Duchene scored the next one. God apparently wanted to see the Avalanche get eliminated in high definition.
Straight second-round exits with a superstar roster and an amateur escape plan
San Jose, Dallas, Vegas. Colorado assembled MacKinnon, Rantanen and Makar, then let the Western Conference take turns demonstrating that three beautiful hockey players do not constitute an entire fucking playoff strategy.
Straight losses to Vegas after the Presidents' Trophy went to Denver's head
Colorado won the Presidents' Trophy and opened against Vegas looking like the official government of hockey. By the elimination game, the Golden Knights had overthrown the entire administration. No recount, just six goals.
Straight Game 7 losses proving Colorado can count to six and panic
MacKinnon once went through three deciding games without a point. Sports television spent months dissecting his legacy, while Colorado's actual solution was apparently to stop scheduling anything that required a seventh game.
Straight defeats in a season when the Avalanche couldn't even manage the downhill part
Denver literally named the team after something that becomes more powerful as it gathers momentum. During that losing streak, the only thing gathering momentum was the argument for changing the name to Colorado Loose Gravel.
Consecutive home losses while Ball Arena pretended Denver had an advantage
Ball Arena sits a mile above sea level, and the Avalanche still found a way to make their own building feel like visiting territory. Opponents came for the altitude training and left with standings points as complimentary souvenirs.
Franchise Game 7 losses, including Quebec's contribution to Denver's bad decisions
Colorado inherited the Nordiques' history, moved the operation to Denver and immediately won a Cup. Quebec had spent years doing the hard part, apparently: developing a franchise someone else could enjoy. The bill for the deciding-game disasters came later.
Power plays pissed away against Dallas by a roster built to score in its sleep
Colorado's power play has Makar on the blue line and MacKinnon loading up a shot that requires municipal approval. Somehow Dallas still made the whole operation look like a very expensive game of keep-away.
Shots blocked by Seattle while Colorado's defending champions fired at shinpads
Seattle blocked so much Colorado offense that the Kraken defense could've opened a construction company. Meanwhile the Avalanche kept firing into traffic like they were being paid by the dent.
Regulation losses in Colorado's catastrophic forty-eight-point season
That Avalanche season was so spectacularly useless, the Rocky Mountains looked down at the standings and requested their name be removed from the promotional material. Even the landscape refused to endorse the product.
Days without a Cup, and Dallas is still renting space in your head
Colorado won the Cup and started acting like the whole league was merely borrowing its trophy. Then the playoff exits returned, and suddenly every conversation in Denver required an extended flashback to the championship parade.
COLORADO TRADED MIKKO. DALLAS SENT BACK A GAME 7 HAT TRICK.
MacFarland's trade machine has one setting: convert a franchise winger into an opposing playoff nightmare. Customer support consists of a receipt and a dial tone.
Participation Trophies
- 2019-20: Second-round Game 7 lost to Dallas on Joel Kiviranta's overtime hat trick.
- 2020-21: Presidents' Trophy season ended with four straight playoff losses to Vegas.
- 2022-23: Defending champions eliminated at home by expansion Seattle in Game 7.
- 2024-25: Power play went 3-for-22 against Dallas before another Game 7 elimination.
- 2016-17: Franchise-worst 48-point season with 56 regulation losses.